Australia Test cricket captain Pat Cummins has strongly rejected claims by former teammate Usman Khawaja regarding the 2018 sandpaper ball tampering scandal. Addressing reporters in Sydney, Cummins labeled Khawaja's allegations that the entire Australian team knew about the scheme as complete and utter nonsense.

Key Facts
- Usman Khawaja claimed in his book Sabr that Australia's entire team knew about the 2018 sandpaper plot.
- Pat Cummins addressed reporters for over an hour in Sydney, calling Khawaja's claims complete nonsense.
- Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg reviewed investigation files and will not reopen the inquiry.
- David Warner supported Khawaja's claims, while Mitchell Starc and Darren Lehmann rejected them.
The extraordinary press conference at Cricket Central in Sydney lasted between 68 and 70 minutes, with Cummins promising to answer every question to bring clarity to the situation. Calling the media gathering himself without formal intervention from Cricket Australia media handlers, the Test captain spent over an hour addressing a crowded room of journalists. Cummins even turned away an official who tried to wrap up the session early, asserting that he wanted to address the topic fully so he would never have to speak about it again, the BBC reported.
The controversy re-emerged following the publication of Khawaja's autobiography, titled Sabr, in which the retired batter claimed that the entire Australian playing XI was aware of the plot to alter the ball during the 2018 Cape Town Test match against South Africa. Khawaja also wrote that Cummins and other senior players were key figures in planning the ball tampering. Cummins forcefully rejected those assertions, stating that if Khawaja meant players knew sandpaper was being taken onto the field, he was completely wrong, adding that he had consistently maintained his innocence for eight years.
Also read: Usman Khawaja Alters Book Tour Over Ball Tampering Claims
Confronting the Allegations and Friendship
During the session, Cummins expressed deep personal frustration over how his long-standing friendship with Khawaja had been tested by the public allegations. The two cricketers played 56 Test matches together and were previously domestic teammates for New South Wales. Cummins noted that while he supports Khawaja's right to tell his story, friends should not be casual with one another's lives and reputations. He revealed that a recorded tense conversation with his wife Becky was driven by her anger over Khawaja's statements, though he confirmed he will not pursue legal action despite receiving advice that some claims were defamatory, Sky Sports reported.
Reactions across the Australian cricket community have been sharply divided since the book's release. Former vice-captain David Warner publicly backed Khawaja's account as fully accurate, whereas fast bowler Mitchell Starc reaffirmed his previous stance, stating that his recollections have not changed since a joint statement issued in 2021. Meanwhile, ODI captain Mitchell Marsh declined to address questions about the book, while former head coach Darren Lehmann and assistant Graeme Hick rejected Khawaja's claims. Former squad member Chadd Sayers expressed support for Khawaja's version of events.
Also read: Cricket Australia Rejects New Sandpapergate Inquiry After Khawaja
Addressing the presence of sandpaper in cricket dressing rooms, Cummins explained that abrasive materials are routinely kept by batters and are frequently used during training sessions to prepare balls for reverse-swing practice. Bowlers and batters often scuff balls on concrete or use tools like Stanley knives in the nets to simulate match conditions, though Cummins insisted such methods were never used illegally on the field during matches. He recalled witnessing illegal ball tampering only once in his career during a domestic Sheffield Shield game involving a bottle cap, which was promptly stopped by match umpires, as reported by The Guardian.
Cummins also addressed the administrative response, confirming he had met with Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg. Greenberg reviewed the file archives from the original 2018 investigation and concluded that the records remained consistent, deciding against reopening the inquiry. Cummins reiterated his personal belief that the original suspensions handed down in 2018 were overly severe, while maintaining that extending those sanctions into wider accusations against the rest of the squad was unwarranted.
Also read: Usman Khawaja Defends Sandpaper Claims on 2018 Australia Team
Addressing Team Culture
Reflecting on his early career during the 2018 tour, when he was a 24-year-old playing in just his 13th Test match, Cummins acknowledged that the team culture at the time had serious flaws. He described an abrasive atmosphere marked by an ugly underbelly and excessive hostility toward opposition players and umpires. Cummins emphasized that since taking over the Test captaincy in late 2021, he has worked diligently to eradicate those negative traits and foster a more respectful environment within the national team.
Background
The sandpaper scandal originated during the third Test against South Africa at Cape Town in March 2018, when field cameras caught Cameron Bancroft using sandpaper to alter the condition of the match ball. The resulting investigation led Cricket Australia to impose a nine-month ban on Bancroft, while captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner each received 12-month suspensions from all international and domestic cricket. Warner was also permanently barred from holding leadership positions within Australian cricket.
In 2021, amid renewed media speculation, the core bowling attack from that Test match, comprising Cummins, Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Nathan Lyon, issued a joint public statement denying any prior knowledge that foreign substances were taken onto the pitch. Later that year, Cummins was appointed Test captain following the resignation of Tim Paine. Khawaja retired from international cricket in January after a distinguished career, but the release of his autobiography has reopened debate surrounding governance, accountability, and lingering questions from the 2018 tour.
Why It Matters
The renewed dispute highlights the persistent strain the 2018 scandal continues to exert on Australian cricket's public standing and team relationships. As current players navigate historical allegations while maintaining focus on ongoing international fixtures, the leadership's ability to maintain unity and preserve cultural reforms remains critical for the sport's reputation.
Representative photo: dhana311 / Pixabay
Sources
- BBC: Pat Cummins calls Usman Khawaja sandpaper claims 'wrong' and 'nonsense'
- The Guardian: ‘Abrasive’, ‘arrogant’ and ‘ugly’: standout moments from Pat Cummins’ sandpapergate press conference
- Sky Sports: Sandpapergate: Australia Test captain Pat Cummins dismisses Usman Khawaja's claims over ball-tampering scandal as 'utter nonsense'